The letter on Scottish Independence in yesterday’s Press and Journal by Ian Walker is absolutely correct.
It is pure fantasy for Alex Salmond to hoodwink the Scottish people into believing that we can have an independent Scotland within the European Union.
We need to waken up to the undeniable fact that the European Union exists for the benefit of the European Union, not for the benefit of the member states.
EU law demands that new member states must accept existing Community legislation in its entirety and subscribe to the common policies. No exceptions can be allowed other than those agreed upon for a transitional period.
So what does the future hold for the fishing industry in an independent Scotland within the EU? - the continuation of the deliberate and decisive destruction of the Scottish fishing fleet, under the pretence of the need for more and more conservation, while at the same time allowing a seal population to explode and consume more fish than the EU allows the industry to catch.
And what does the future hold for us all with so called independence in the European Union?
There would be nothing but political intrusion, suppression and diktat while commanded to hand over billions of pounds a year for illusory benefits
The idea that Scottish fishermen will, somehow, do well out of that weird status of "independence within the EU" is, as Sandy Patience, says, complete fantasy. Unsurprisingly, many other people in Scotland may realize this truth. According to the top news story in the same newspaper:
VOTERS across northern Scotland have said no to independence in a survey commissioned by the Press and Journal.
And they want to have their say on the issue now – not in 2014, when the SNP says it will put the question to the nation.
Nearly 45% of those polled said they would reject the chance to let Scotland go it alone.
That may be why Alex Salmond wants to postpone the referendum.